diff --git a/apps/frontend/src/components/ui/ProjectDownloadModal/CompatibleVersionCard.vue b/apps/frontend/src/components/ui/ProjectDownloadModal/CompatibleVersionCard.vue
index 1f26104bb2..fc15c34c5a 100644
--- a/apps/frontend/src/components/ui/ProjectDownloadModal/CompatibleVersionCard.vue
+++ b/apps/frontend/src/components/ui/ProjectDownloadModal/CompatibleVersionCard.vue
@@ -1,7 +1,25 @@
 <template>
 	<div
-		class="grid grid-cols-[1fr_min-content] items-center gap-3 rounded-2xl bg-surface-2 px-3 py-3"
+		:role="selectable ? 'radio' : undefined"
+		:aria-checked="selectable ? selected : undefined"
+		:tabindex="selectable ? 0 : undefined"
+		class="grid items-center gap-3 rounded-2xl border border-solid px-3 py-3 transition-all"
+		:class="{
+			'grid-cols-[min-content_minmax(0,1fr)_min-content]': selectable,
+			'grid-cols-[minmax(0,1fr)_min-content]': !selectable,
+			'cursor-pointer border-brand bg-surface-4 text-contrast': selectable && selected,
+			'cursor-pointer border-surface-5 bg-surface-4 hover:brightness-[115%]':
+				selectable && !selected,
+			'border-transparent bg-surface-2': !selectable,
+		}"
+		@click="select"
+		@keydown.enter.self.prevent="select"
+		@keydown.space.self.prevent="select"
 	>
+		<template v-if="selectable">
+			<RadioButtonCheckedIcon v-if="selected" aria-hidden="true" class="size-5 text-brand" />
+			<RadioButtonIcon v-else aria-hidden="true" class="size-5 text-secondary" />
+		</template>
 		<div class="flex min-w-0 flex-col gap-1">
 			<div class="flex min-w-0 items-center gap-2">
 				<nuxt-link
@@ -21,13 +39,21 @@
 				<span v-tooltip="publishedTooltip" class="min-w-0 truncate capitalize">
 					{{ publishedLabel }}
 				</span>
-				<div v-if="primaryFile" class="h-1.5 w-1.5 flex-shrink-0 rounded-full bg-surface-5"></div>
+				<div
+					v-if="primaryFile"
+					class="h-1.5 w-1.5 flex-shrink-0 rounded-full bg-primary opacity-30"
+				></div>
 				<span v-if="primaryFile" class="flex-shrink-0">
 					{{ primaryFileSizeLabel }}
 				</span>
 			</div>
 		</div>
-		<ButtonStyled v-if="primaryFile" :color="color" :type="type" :circular="circular">
+		<ButtonStyled
+			v-if="primaryFile && showDownload"
+			:color="color"
+			:type="type"
+			:circular="circular"
+		>
 			<a
 				v-tooltip="circular ? formatMessage(messages.download) : null"
 				:href="primaryFileDownloadUrl"
@@ -50,7 +76,7 @@
 
 <script setup lang="ts">
 import type { Labrinth } from '@modrinth/api-client'
-import { DownloadIcon } from '@modrinth/assets'
+import { DownloadIcon, RadioButtonCheckedIcon, RadioButtonIcon } from '@modrinth/assets'
 import {
 	ButtonStyled,
 	type CdnDownloadReason,
@@ -84,6 +110,9 @@ const props = withDefaults(
 		color?: 'brand' | 'standard'
 		type?: 'standard' | 'transparent'
 		circular?: boolean
+		selectable?: boolean
+		selected?: boolean
+		showDownload?: boolean
 	}>(),
 	{
 		downloadReason: 'standalone',
@@ -92,11 +121,15 @@ const props = withDefaults(
 		color: 'brand',
 		type: 'standard',
 		circular: false,
+		selectable: false,
+		selected: false,
+		showDownload: true,
 	},
 )
 
 const emit = defineEmits<{
 	download: []
+	select: []
 }>()
 
 const { createProjectDownloadUrl } = useCdnDownloadContext()
@@ -131,6 +164,11 @@ const primaryFileSizeLabel = computed(() => {
 	return formatBytes(primaryFile.value.size)
 })
 
+function select() {
+	if (!props.selectable) return
+	emit('select')
+}
+
 const messages = defineMessages({
 	downloadVersion: {
 		id: 'project.download.download-version',
diff --git a/apps/frontend/src/components/ui/ProjectDownloadModal/DownloadProject.vue b/apps/frontend/src/components/ui/ProjectDownloadModal/DownloadProject.vue
index e60e3493ed..8985efefb9 100644
--- a/apps/frontend/src/components/ui/ProjectDownloadModal/DownloadProject.vue
+++ b/apps/frontend/src/components/ui/ProjectDownloadModal/DownloadProject.vue
@@ -80,35 +80,47 @@
 		</Combobox>
 	</div>
 
-	<div v-if="selectedVersion && downloadDataLoaded" class="flex flex-col gap-2.5">
+	<div
+		v-if="selectedVersion && downloadDataLoaded"
+		:role="compatibleVersions.length > 1 ? 'radiogroup' : undefined"
+		:aria-label="
+			compatibleVersions.length > 1 ? formatMessage(messages.compatibleVersionTitle) : undefined
+		"
+		class="flex flex-col gap-2.5"
+	>
 		<h3
-			v-if="[...suggestedPreReleaseVersions, selectedVersion].length > 1"
+			v-if="compatibleVersions.length > 1"
 			class="relative top-0.5 m-0 text-base font-semibold text-contrast"
 		>
 			{{ formatMessage(messages.compatibleVersionTitle) }}
 		</h3>
 		<CompatibleVersionCard
+			v-for="compatibleVersion in compatibleVersions"
+			:key="compatibleVersion.id"
 			:project="project"
-			:version="selectedVersion"
+			:version="compatibleVersion"
 			:download-reason="downloadReason"
 			:current-game-version="currentGameVersion"
 			:current-platform="currentPlatform"
-			:color="hasAdditionalDownloads ? 'standard' : 'brand'"
-			:type="hasAdditionalDownloads ? 'transparent' : 'standard'"
-			:circular="hasAdditionalDownloads"
-			@download="emit('download')"
-		/>
-		<CompatibleVersionCard
-			v-for="suggestedVersion in suggestedPreReleaseVersions"
-			:key="suggestedVersion.version.id"
-			:project="project"
-			:version="suggestedVersion.version"
-			:download-reason="downloadReason"
-			:current-game-version="currentGameVersion"
-			:current-platform="currentPlatform"
-			color="standard"
-			type="transparent"
-			circular
+			:selectable="compatibleVersions.length > 1"
+			:selected="compatibleVersion.id === selectedVersion.id"
+			:show-download="compatibleVersions.length === 1 || compatibleVersion.id === selectedVersion.id"
+			:color="
+				compatibleVersion.id === selectedVersion.id &&
+				compatibleVersions.length === 1 &&
+				!hasAdditionalDownloads
+					? 'brand'
+					: 'standard'
+			"
+			:type="
+				compatibleVersion.id === selectedVersion.id &&
+				compatibleVersions.length === 1 &&
+				!hasAdditionalDownloads
+					? 'standard'
+					: 'transparent'
+			"
+			:circular="hasAdditionalDownloads || compatibleVersions.length > 1"
+			@select="selectCompatibleVersion(compatibleVersion)"
 			@download="emit('download')"
 		/>
 	</div>
@@ -154,10 +166,6 @@ type DownloadableFile = {
 	filename: string
 }
 
-type SuggestedPreReleaseVersion = {
-	version: Labrinth.Versions.v3.Version
-}
-
 const props = withDefaults(
 	defineProps<{
 		project: DownloadModalProject
@@ -196,6 +204,7 @@ const tags = useGeneratedState()
 
 const userSelectedGameVersion = ref<string | null>(props.initialGameVersion)
 const userSelectedPlatform = ref<string | null>(props.initialPlatform)
+const userSelectedCompatibleVersionId = ref<string | null>(null)
 const showAllVersions = ref(defaultShowAllVersions())
 const versionFilter = ref('')
 
@@ -367,10 +376,42 @@ const filteredAlpha = computed<Labrinth.Versions.v3.Version | undefined>(() => {
 	return latestVersionByType('alpha')
 })
 
-const selectedVersion = computed<Labrinth.Versions.v3.Version | null>(() => {
+const defaultSelectedVersion = computed<Labrinth.Versions.v3.Version | null>(() => {
 	return filteredRelease.value || filteredBeta.value || filteredAlpha.value || null
 })
 
+const suggestedPreReleaseVersions = computed<Labrinth.Versions.v3.Version[]>(() => {
+	if (!defaultSelectedVersion.value || defaultSelectedVersion.value.version_type !== 'release') return []
+
+	const versions: Labrinth.Versions.v3.Version[] = []
+	const beta = filteredBeta.value
+	if (beta && isNewerThan(beta, defaultSelectedVersion.value)) {
+		versions.push(beta)
+	}
+
+	const alpha = filteredAlpha.value
+	if (alpha && isNewerThan(alpha, defaultSelectedVersion.value)) {
+		versions.push(alpha)
+	}
+
+	return versions
+})
+
+const compatibleVersions = computed<Labrinth.Versions.v3.Version[]>(() => {
+	if (!defaultSelectedVersion.value) return []
+	return [defaultSelectedVersion.value, ...suggestedPreReleaseVersions.value]
+})
+
+const selectedVersion = computed<Labrinth.Versions.v3.Version | null>(() => {
+	return (
+		compatibleVersions.value.find(
+			(version) => version.id === userSelectedCompatibleVersionId.value,
+		) ||
+		defaultSelectedVersion.value ||
+		null
+	)
+})
+
 const selectedPrimaryFile = computed<Labrinth.Versions.v3.VersionFile | null>(() => {
 	return (
 		selectedVersion.value?.files?.find((file) => file.primary) ||
@@ -379,27 +420,6 @@ const selectedPrimaryFile = computed<Labrinth.Versions.v3.VersionFile | null>(()
 	)
 })
 
-const suggestedPreReleaseVersions = computed<SuggestedPreReleaseVersion[]>(() => {
-	if (!selectedVersion.value || selectedVersion.value.version_type !== 'release') return []
-
-	const versions: SuggestedPreReleaseVersion[] = []
-	const beta = filteredBeta.value
-	if (beta && isNewerThan(beta, selectedVersion.value)) {
-		versions.push({
-			version: beta,
-		})
-	}
-
-	const alpha = filteredAlpha.value
-	if (alpha && isNewerThan(alpha, selectedVersion.value)) {
-		versions.push({
-			version: alpha,
-		})
-	}
-
-	return versions
-})
-
 const hasAdditionalDownloads = computed(() => {
 	const hrefs = new Set<string>()
 
@@ -428,11 +448,16 @@ watch(
 	{ immediate: true },
 )
 
+watch([currentGameVersion, currentPlatform], () => {
+	userSelectedCompatibleVersionId.value = null
+})
+
 watch(
 	() => props.resetKey,
 	() => {
 		userSelectedGameVersion.value = props.initialGameVersion
 		userSelectedPlatform.value = props.initialPlatform
+		userSelectedCompatibleVersionId.value = null
 		showAllVersions.value = defaultShowAllVersions()
 		versionFilter.value = ''
 	},
@@ -451,6 +476,10 @@ function selectPlatform(platform?: string) {
 	emit('selectPlatform', platform)
 }
 
+function selectCompatibleVersion(version: Labrinth.Versions.v3.Version) {
+	userSelectedCompatibleVersionId.value = version.id
+}
+
 function latestVersionByType(type: Labrinth.Versions.v3.VersionChannel) {
 	return filteredVersions.value
 		.filter((version) => version.version_type === type)